HEINRICH
H. RUDERT, MD; JOCHEN A. WERNER, MD; STEFFEN HOFT, MD
KIEL, GERMANY
Between 1981 and 1994, 34 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the
supraglottis were treated by transoral carbon dioxide laser resection,
12 of them palliatively. Additional treatment included neck dissection
in 21 patients and radiotherapy in 24 patients. The 3-year overall survival
was 62%, and the actuarial survival 80%. The overall survival for Tl and
T2 tumors was 71%, and that for T3 and T4 tumors was 47%. The overall 3-year
survival for the early stages, I and II, was 88%, and that for the advanced
stages, III and IV, was 50%. These results are comparable to the outcome
after conventional open partial resection. Given the significantly lower
morbidity (only 7 patients required tracheostomy), we do not observe an
age limit anymore. The transoral method can be recommended as curative
treatment in Tl and T2 tumors and in selected T3 and T4 tumors in concert
with neck dissection and/or radiotherapy. In patients with advanced inoperable
tumors, laser surgery is an excellent alternative to tracheostomy and palliative
radiotherapy. Prerequisites for successful application of the transoral
carbon dioxide laser resection are adequate resection techniques. |