David G. Hanson, MD, Jack J. Jiang, MD, PhD, Judy Chen,Barbara
Roa Pauloski, PhD
Sixteen patients who had symptoms and signs of chronic posterior laryngitis
were evaluated before, during, and after treatment with omeprazole and
nocturnal antireflux precautions. Data were analyzed for patients who complained
of some hoarseness, who had no smoking history, and who completed ail of
the voice recording protocol. The patients' voices were recorded before,
during, and following treatment with omeprazole and nocturnal antireflux
precautions. Voice quality was analyzed by perceptual analysis, and acoustic
signal data were measured for jitter shimmer, and signal-to-noise ratio.
Measures of jitter, shimmer, and signal-to-noise ratio changed significantly
with treatment of posterior laryngitis (p < .01 for change in each of the
measures). Acoustic measures showed Sonic trend of deterioration with cessation
of treatment, although the overall improvement in acoustic measures of
voice quality was still statistically significant after treatment with
omeprazole was discontinued. Although perceived abnormality of voice increased
and decreased with the magnitude of measured perturbation of the acoustic
signal for some patients, the perceptual assessments were not highly correlated
with acoustic measures for individual patients, and the perceptual analysis
group data did not show a significant change with time during treatment,
in contrast to the significance of change in acoustic measures. The data
demonstrate that acoustic measures of jitter, shimmer, and signal to-noise
ratio improve significantly with antisecretory and antireflux treatment
of chronic posterior laryngitis, and that for individual patients. these
are changes that are detected by trained listeners, but not at statistically
high levels of confidence.
|